In the first in our new series of studio roundtables, and following our work for Dead&Co at the Las Vegas Sphere, we sat down with some of the Art&Graft team to discuss all things immersive: nausea-inducing visuals, the joy of collective experience, and VR pipelines.
Could you talk through some of the key challenges and successes of the Dead&Co project?
Freddie: The scale of the Sphere was huge, so with that comes massive opportunities, but massive lessons too. You’re working on these small turtles on a screen, but they’re going to be blown up to the size of a small house.
Another challenge was working within a live concert for a band which might do a 10 minute guitar solo. We had an idea of the sequence but had to plan ideas that could be looped in case the song looped. But all the detail and effort really was worth it.
It’s such a thrill to see our work displayed at such a large scale and in front of a live audience.
Morgane: My challenges were similar, but because Freddie had gone through them I was more prepared. Every time we separated the different layers of the illustration to animate them, if you missed a little speck of paint there would be someone dancing, and they’re going to have a huge speck of paint next to them.
Working with illustrations for the Stanley Mouse segment that were not made with animation in mind was a big responsibility — you want to do them justice.
What sort of limitations did you face working on such a large scale?
Freddie: We wrestled with speed — something which looked smooth or subtle on screen is so different on a large scale, there’s no give. If there’s even the slightest bit of a frame that pops it’s like watching a house size pop, it’s really unforgiving.
Can you talk about the VR / Sphere pipeline?
Freddie: We used a VR headset which was useful for seeing scale, the space and different perspectives. The background was a 12k drawing, which was small on my screen, but in the Sphere there’ll be a section where it looked really sparse.
So you’re like, oh, I’m gonna have to put in some trees to fill something in which wouldn’t necessarily look empty on your screen. Without that there would have been more hurdles. As Morgane said, you might have accidentally touched the screen with your pen and you wouldn’t even see it, but in there it’s massive.
What makes an experience truly immersive from a design perspective?
Ieuan: I think it’s when you’re rooted in the story or space, it surrounds you and you engage because it’s not linear. There’s something about when you forget what’s around you — that moment where you break away from reality. The longer you stay out of the real world, the more you’re immersed.
It’s context with the Sphere: the atmosphere without anyone there would be very different than a full crowd — it’s part of the performance. You’re not just looking at the screen like when you see a film, there’s more going on. It’s the way people engage with the space, get excited and embrace that moment together.
Felix: When you make a piece where people sit and forget about everything else, it doesn’t matter about the size of the screen or the artwork, for me, that’s being immersed. There’s a difference between interactive and immersive, even though they come hand in hand.
Freddie: I’m immersed in TV or film, and invested in a narrative or world building. That can be singular or collective, but the difference with a concert is being collectively immersed with a crowd. The feeling is less about the narrative or storyline, it’s visuals and sound combined to this shared experience. Those two things feel different, but I can equally be immersed in one thing and the other.
Have you been to any immersive experiences?
Morgane: I went to the Van Gogh exhibit. For me it didn’t feel immersive, because it’s just blown up paintings; it didn’t tell a story. It needs to be a whole sensory experience — for Sphere, if you have the animation but you don’t have the band and everybody dancing, it wouldn’t work.
I also went to a show at the South London Gallery in Peckham. There was a VR headset, and you were in a giant fish tank. If you sang, the fish would change colours, and swim towards you. It was amazing, sensory and intuitive, and you could shape the scene like a video game.
At the start you’re clumsy, and you keep thinking about people queuing up to sing nonsense. You have to forget about yourself, your embarrassment, and become really immersed. You take the headset off and walk out and everyone’s looking at you.
Freddie: There’s something in that, to be truly immersed to the point where your social anxieties disappear.
Ieuan: The sensory thing feels like a huge part, it separates it from cinema — you need more inputs for it to be immersive.
Felix: It’s interesting what you said about it reacting to you, rather than you reacting. You can shape stuff, you are the centre, you decide where things go.
Morgane: I’ve been to Outernet, and had different experiences. The first time was an animated painting inspired by the Sistine Chapel. It was immersive and the sound was so loud that you couldn’t hear the streets.
You could feel the excitement — everyone was captivated, watching it together. The second time I went it was a bit flatter, and the music felt like it didn’t connect. People were just walking around looking at different parts of the room.
Ieuan: I went to Lightroom which is an incredible space – every surface is a screen. But unless it’s used thoughtfully there is this temptation to just look at one wall. You need a good reason to turn your head because you’re essentially watching a film.
With immersive experiences there has to be a reason, a “why?”. Why is it not a film, because films are very effective. It’s a social media thing as well. Outernet is where it is so everyone can walk through. Brands can take over, and people can take a photo in this immersive experience — it’s Instagrammable.
Will VR ever overtake physical experiences?
Ieuan: I’m not sure if it will. When you watch something live, there are variables that you can’t perfect, and there’s magic in that. The best immersive experiences are when you’re in a space that’s been curated as a physical experience like the Sphere, and your guard drops.
Felix: I think VR is more exciting on a professional level than on an entertainment level. The main selling point for entertainment is that you can share it with someone else, and the moment you put a VR headset on you can’t share it anymore.
Sphere feels like it’s trying hard to appeal to social media. Is it still successful?
Freddie: A lot of the conversations were about are we watching the screen or are we watching the Dead&Co? It’s finding that balance. The stuff that gets shared to social media is probably the stuff where you’re not looking at the band, and is that appropriate for a whole show? Probably not.
But those moments are really effective at reaching a wider audience, and they’re also the moments people probably remember the most. They’re the reason you want to see Dead&Co there and not in a standard venue.
What’s the future of immersive motion design?
Felix: I think less is more. The more people try to immerse you, the less successful it is. Clarity of experience is key.
Ieuan: From a UX and UI point of view there’s a lot of design thinking. When you look at an iPhone and the instinctive gestures we use, a lot of that will play into VR. What the controller is, how it works: they want it to feel habitual.
We don’t even think about how we look at the camera on our phone and it unlocks — these things are intuitive. The way in which that is designed will be informed through good motion and design principles.
Vienna to London and 3D design from the physical to the digital.
Bespoke design systems that flex and adapt for your brand.
The magical world of character design, Samurai Jack and Sphere Las Vegas.
A mammoth, immersive colour by numbers sequence at Sphere Las Vegas.
A mammoth colour by numbers sequence, a breathtaking wrap-around experience, an animation of epic resolution, design aided by the latest VR technology, a flurry of birds, a rainbow-adorned idyll, the 1977 stars of Terrapin Station.